Mark As Completed Discussion

Strategy Prototyping: From Python to C++

Why this screen matters

  • You will normally prototype quickly in Python (pandas/NumPy) to validate strategy logic. When the inner loop becomes a bottleneck, you migrate just that hotspot to C++ for speed and deterministic performance.
  • Think of Python as your whiteboard sketch and C++ as the high-performance court — the plays are the same, but execution is faster and more precise.

High-level workflow (ASCII diagram)

Python prototype (fast iterate) ---> Profile (cProfile/line_profiler/pyinstrument) ---> Identify hot function(s) ---> Reimplement hot function(s) in C++ (pybind11 or RPC) ---> Integrate & benchmark ---> Deploy

Analogy for beginners (basketball)

  • Prototype in Python = film-study with Kobe Bryant highlights. You find the play that scores most often.
  • Hotspot = the quick cut that wins the game (micro-ops inside your loop).
  • Migrating to C++ = sending your best shooter to the court who always hits under pressure.

Concrete tips for a beginner in C++, Python, Java, C, JS

  • Prototype quickly in Python: use small, readable code & synthetic ticks (lists of (timestamp, price, size)).
  • Profile early: find the exact function (not the file) that takes most time—funcA doing rolling sums? that's your candidate.
  • Reimplement minimally: keep the same inputs/outputs. Start with a small, well-tested C++ function that computes e.g. a rolling average or VWAP.
  • Expose to Python: start with pybind11 (a thin wrapper). If deployment needs process isolation, use an RPC boundary (nanomsg, gRPC, or raw TCP).

What to migrate (common hotspots)

  • Inner loops that process every tick (aggregation, feature extraction, order decision logic).
  • Parsing heavy binary formats (market ITCH/OUCH) — low-level parsers in C++ can drastically reduce CPU and copies.
  • Memory-allocation hot spots — re-use buffers in C++ and avoid per-tick malloc.

Quick checklist before migrating

  • Can I vectorize this in NumPy? If yes, you may not need C++.
  • Is the function called millions of times per second? If yes, it's a prime candidate.
  • Are allocations and copies dominating CPU? Move to a C++ ring buffer.

Mini-exercise (what the C++ code below demonstrates)

  • Generates a stream of synthetic prices (deterministic seed so results are reproducible).
  • Implements two ways to compute a rolling simple moving average (SMA):
    • naive_sma: recompute the sum each tick (like a straightforward Python loop).
    • incremental_sma: maintain an incremental sum (how you'd implement it in C++ for speed).
  • Compares timings so you can see why migrating the inner loop matters.

Try these challenges after running the example

  • Change the window size (WINDOW) and re-run. How does the speed gap evolve?
  • Replace the random tick generator with a small histogram or real CSV replay (simulate Kobe Bryant moments by injecting spikes).
  • Wrap the incremental_sma in pybind11 and call it from Python for a real prototype -> production path.

Now run the C++ example below (it prints timings and a few sample buy decisions). Then try the challenges!

CPP
OUTPUT
:001 > Cmd/Ctrl-Enter to run, Cmd/Ctrl-/ to comment